| Abstract|| |
Objectives: Saudi Arabia launched multiple initiatives to overcome the problem of health-care access. The recent coronavirus pandemic created urgent demand to deal with the problem using nonconventional venues such as telehealth and teledentistry. This study aimed to investigate teledentistry knowledge, attitudes, and practices, and barriers to its use among dental students and teaching staff in Makkah province, Saudi Arabia. Materials and Methods: A total of 314 dental students participated in this cross-sectional study. Data were collected using a validated self-reported questionnaire to measure teledentistry awareness, attitude, practices, and barriers to teledentistry. The study was approved by Umm Al-Qura University, Saudi Arabia. Results: Only 17.2% were aware of the term “teledentistry.” However, after it was explained, participants were able to correctly answer 25.16%–62.42% of items about teledentistry. A total of 67.83% would practice teledentistry, and 70.7% support using teledentistry on a national scale for Vision 2030. Only 25.16% used teledentistry before, but 56.05% did dental consultations via smartphone. The most common barriers were patient satisfaction requiring a dentist’s physical presence, violation of patient privacy, and low levels of population education. Conclusion: Dental students seem to know little about teledentistry. However, they are open to learning and using it. It is encouraged to include the topic in continuing dental education, including how to use it during health disasters such as the coronavirus pandemic.
Keywords: Teledentistry, telehealth, COVID-19, Vision 2030, attitude, barriers, dental students, knowledge, Saudi Arabia
|How to cite this article:|
Aboalshamat KT. Awareness of, beliefs about, practices of, and barriers to teledentistry among dental students and the implications for Saudi Arabia Vision 2030 and coronavirus pandemic. J Int Soc Prevent Communit Dent 2020;10:431-7
|How to cite this URL:|
Aboalshamat KT. Awareness of, beliefs about, practices of, and barriers to teledentistry among dental students and the implications for Saudi Arabia Vision 2030 and coronavirus pandemic. J Int Soc Prevent Communit Dent [serial online] 2020 [cited 2020 Nov 24];10:431-7. Available from: https://www.jispcd.org/text.asp?2020/10/4/431/291451
| Introduction|| |
Inadequate access to health care is a major challenge worldwide, and the challenge includes access to oral health care. In fact, the current coronavirus pandemic created an urgent demand to deal with the problem using nonconventional methods such as telehealth.,, In the last 4 years, Saudi Arabia had launched multiple initiatives to overcome health-care access problems, including privatization of the health-care system; however, a critical review of the body of literature indicated that privatization alone might not be sufficient to overcome the problem. In fact, there is a shortage and uneven distribution of the dental workforce between the provinces of Saudi Arabia, which accentuates the problem’s complexity. Thus, it is important to pay attention to more innovative modalities and use technology such as teledentistry to overcome the oral health-care accessibility problem.
Teledentistry, as a part of telehealth, can be defined as the use of telecommunications and technology in dental care and dental education interactions over a distance.,, Teledentistry is still considered new, given that it was first used by the US Army in 1994. Teledentistry seems to be a promising model because it overcomes social boundaries and geographical gaps in the existing resources of developed countries. It was found to be useful for underserved and remote areas of different countries around the world.,,
Currently, the coronavirus pandemic (known as coronavirus disease 2019 [COVID-19]) has made more attention to the potential uses of telehealth,,, including teledentistry. In fact, the pandemic made high restrictions on elective medical and dental clinic visits, as visits were permitted to emergency cases in many countries.,, The social distancing and movement restriction was taken as a measure to help controlling the spread of the disease in many countries in the world. Also, the COVID-19 has a potential to paralyze the health system in the light of the basic health requirements to cope with the pandemic. Thus, it was suggested that using telehealth might be a useful tool for “forward triage” before emergency cases reach the hospital and to facilitate medical professional–patient communication. This was applied in China for tertiary dental cases in 48 dental hospitals. Nevertheless, despite all of the promising studies in the literature about using the technology, it could be hindered by unexpected factors such as the resistance of dentists to using teledentistry.
Therefore, to achieve a better implementation of teledentistry, it is important to understand the current state of knowledge, beliefs, and practices about it among current and future dentists. The comparison of results in the literature indicated that the knowledge about teledentistry differs by country, level of education, and years of experience.,,,, For example, 74.4%–88.6% of dentists in India and Rwanda were aware of teledentistry,,,, as compared to 37.4% in Pakistan. Dental students were found to be less knowledgeable and enthusiastic about teledentistry than dental faculty or practicing dentists. In fact, years of experience had an inverse relationship with the level of knowledge about teledentistry. Despite many studies showing that most dentists and dental students wished to practice teledentistry in the future,, approximately 26%–31.4% of dentists did not think that teledentistry was efficient in many respects., Some studies found that no dentists had practiced teledentistry in Pakistan, and very few (6.8%) had in Rwanda., The studies also highlighted some barriers to teledentistry implementation that included the high cost of the technology, lack of available technology, lack of human resources, lack of computer skills among dentists, and the need to perform manual work rather than online procedures.
Currently, in Saudi Arabia, a major reform road map (Vision 2030) drives the country’s initiatives into a new era in major domains such as health, economy, and technology. Saudi Vision 2020 has three themes: vibrant society, thriving economy, and ambitious nation. These themes allocate into 96 strategic goals. Teledentistry seems to be a very important topic for investigation in Saudi Arabia because it can contribute greatly to three strategic goals of Vision 2030: “2.1. Improve healthcare service,” “5.2.4. Develop the e-government,” and “5.2.5. Improve the quality of services provided to citizens.”  Furthermore, teledentistry can be useful in Makkah holy city, which hosts more than 6 million Muslim worshipers annually from around the world to perform Umrah and Hajj. This number is planned to be 30 million in Vision 2030, and Saudi Arabia is implementing many fast-paced initiatives to achieve this strategic goal. Thus, it is important to investigate such technology, and the levels of awareness, beliefs, and practices of teledentistry among Saudi dentists; dental students, as the future dental workforce; and dental faculty, who provide students with the latest about dentistry, for better implementation.
Yet, no other article was found that investigated the current levels of awareness about teledentistry in Saudi Arabia among dental students and faculty members. Thus, this study aimed to investigate the levels of knowledge, attitudes about, practices of, and barriers to teledentistry among dental students and teaching staff in Makkah province, Saudi Arabia.
| Materials and Methods|| |
A cross-sectional study was conducted in November 2019 to assess the current levels of knowledge, attitudes about, practices of, and barriers to teledentistry among dental students at Umm Al-Qura University, King Abdulaziz University, Ibn Sina colleges, Albatatrji Medical colleges, and Alfarabi dental colleges in Makkah province, Saudi Arabia. The inclusion criteria included students from the second to the sixth year, in addition to dental intern. The exclusion criteria included graduate dentist or dropped dental students. The students were recruited to complete the study questionnaire during their breaks on workdays, and the inclusion criteria were dental students from second year to internship. Data were collected through a hard-copy self-administered questionnaire in English, which took approximately 10 min to complete. All participants were required to sign a consent form before starting the questionnaire. All data were used anonymously, and all identifiable information was discarded.
The questionnaire had five sections comprising the following. Section One collected demographic information. Section Two consisted of 11 questions with true or false answers, designed to assess knowledge about teledentistry, with answers totaled for a score ranging from 0 to 11 (highest level of knowledge). Prior to those questions, the correct meaning of the teledentistry concept was explained, but because participants might be practicing teledentistry without being familiar with the term, the explanation included a note not to change previous answers. Section Three consisted of 10 questions regarding participant attitudes toward teledentistry, using a Likert scale from 1 to 5. Section Four included seven questions about practicing teledentistry. Lastly, Section Five included eight possible barriers to the use of teledentistry, and participants were to state whether or not they agreed that it was a barrier with a yes or no answer. The questionnaire was derived from previous literature, with modifications.,,,, A pilot test with 10 participants validated the questionnaire for logical flow, organization, language, syntax, and content. The questionnaire has good reliability as Cronbach α ranged between 0.67 and 0.82.
Data were analyzed by using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) software program, version 21.0 (IBM, Armonk, New York). Descriptive data included mean (m), standard deviation (SD), frequency, and proportions. The research questions were tested with multiple regression and t test, and statistical significance was set at a P-value of 0.05. Data were entered via private computer with password protection and could be accessed only by the principal investigator. This study was approved by the Faculty of Dentistry Institutional Review Board of Umm Al-Qura University, Saudi Arabia (129-19).
| Results|| |
A total of 314 dental students and interns with a mean age of 23.06 (SD = 1.63) completed the study questionnaire. [Table 1] shows participant demographic data.
There were only 54 (17.2%) participants who had previously heard of teledentistry, but 44 (14%) were able to identify the true meaning of “teledentistry.”
For the 11 questions regarding knowledge about teledentistry, the mean score for correct answers was 5.55 (SD = 2.56). Multivariable regression and backward elimination showed that the total knowledge score was not statistically significant with regard to gender, college, age, or previous knowledge. The percentages of correct answers for each item are shown in [Table 2].
|Table 2: Percentage of participants correctly answering teledentistry knowledge items|
Click here to view
Participant practices of teledentistry activities are reported in [Table 3]. A significantly higher percentage of female respondents had conducted consultations via smartphone, and they were more willing to practice teledentistry, whereas a higher percentage of male students had attended lectures about teledentistry. Also, a higher ratio of students from private dental colleges had conducted consultations using smartphones, attended lectures about teledentistry, and received hands-on training in teledentistry, as shown in [Table 3]. Participants’ beliefs about teledentistry and their opinions on the barriers to its use are shown in [Table 4] and [Table 5], respectively.
| Discussion|| |
The level of awareness about teledentistry among participants in our study was lower than similar studies conducted in Pakistan, India, and Rwanda, which ranged from 37.4% to 88.6%,,,, However, 25.16% of the participants mentioned in the first section that they had previously used teledentistry, which could be because students were unaware of term “teledentistry.” Nevertheless, this percentage is still lower than the proportions in other studies. One of the reasons for the discrepancy with other studies is that most of those studies included graduated dentists, in contrast to our study, which included only students and interns. Another explanation is that this difference is due to the usage of telehealth in different countries. It was indicated that some countries, including Saudi Arabia, face many challenges with using telehealth in general, such as a general distrust of electronic business, privacy concerns, cultural factors, adoption by users, and technological infrastructure. Also, a recent systematic review concluded that the e-health system in Saudi Arabia is growing thanks to the efforts of Vision 2030 and the goals planned for the year 2020, but the review also stated that these goals were not completely fulfilled.
In fact, even after explaining the correct meaning of teledentistry, the participants in our study had only a moderate level of knowledge, with the mean equal to the midpoint. The percentages of correct answers for each item were not high, and more than three-fourths were not aware that teledentistry can help by providing better communication and decreasing the level of isolation between general practitioners and specialists. The level of knowledge was not related to gender, type of college, or age, which means that this lack of knowledge is generalized. This indicates that the students lacked significant amounts of information about the abilities and benefits that teledentistry could offer, if adopted, to improve dental services. This is supported by our finding that only 17.52% had ever attended a lecture about teledentistry.
It is surprising that in our study, 25.16% had previously used teledentistry, despite the low levels of knowledge about the term itself. This proportion is actually higher than that found in similar studies in Pakistan and Rwanda (0%–6.8%)., One reason for this might be the growing usage of e-health systems that accompanies Vision 2030. However, our results are in line with other studies indicating that the majority of dental professionals are willing to practice teledentistry, and support such an initiative on a national scale.
It is interesting to note that more than half of the dental students in our study had used a smartphone for dental consultations, and one-fifth had received hands-on dental training using a teledentistry system. This might indicate that dental students are engaged in teledentistry as a part of the digital transformation of the country along with increased use of smartphone devices and social media in their personal and professional lives. A recent article indicated that 52.76% of dental students and dentists in Saudi Arabia use social media to communicate with their patients. However, the same article highlighted that many dental professionals lack proper guidelines for using such devices in relation to patient privacy. Therefore, it might be important to augment teledentistry educational courses with proper guidelines for professional communication and privacy. Also, as opposed to students in governmental colleges, students in private dental colleges were found to have significantly higher smartphone use for consultations with patients and were also more likely to have attended workshops about teledentistry. This might reflect the variance in educational content between these types of colleges when it comes to modern trends.
With regard to opinions, the dental students in our study had good impressions of teledentistry in general. Two-thirds of the participants believed that teledentistry is useful, which is higher than similar studies (26%–31.4%)., In fact, around half the participants agreed that teledentistry is useful in education, saves time, and should be used in addition to regular dentistry for convenient oral care delivery. However, around one-third believed that teledentistry does not reduce the cost of a dental practice and that teledentistry might be less accurate than dental clinic consultations. It should be noted that a systematic review concluded that teledentistry had an acceptable level of accuracy in the diagnosis of dental caries, but the investigated studies were not of high quality.
More importantly, one-third of respondents also think that teledentistry might violate patient privacy, and it was ranked by participants as one of the most significant barriers to teledentistry use. This perspective was shared by Turkish dental professionals. A systematic review revealed that telehealth privacy in general differs depending on location and setting, and more studies should be implemented that focus on improving privacy and security, taking into account providers’ preferences to keep data safe. Thus, privacy is one of the important aspects that plans for Vision 2030 should carefully consider.
Participants reported several barriers to the use of teledentistry. Around half indicated that patient satisfaction is linked to the dentist’s presence. A similar point was noted by a study in Pakistan, which indicated that dentistry requires manual work. Also, around half of the participants do not trust the general population’s level of education with regard to teledentistry. This claim can be refuted, however, thanks to many changes over the last several years with e-government, which linked many services for citizens for vital personal services to electronic systems such as Absher, in line with Vision 2030. In fact, recently, primary health-care appointments have been moved to the Absher platform. This indicated that teledentistry can be implemented on larger scale across Saudi Arabia fulfilling the strategic goals of improving healthcare service, the e-government, and improving the quality of citizen services. Also, using teledentistry for Muslim visitors from around the world for Umrah and Hajj can be beneficial to overcome the relative shortage of dental workforce in Makkah city, in comparison to the high number of Muslim visitors annually, and reduces the burden of poor communication due to differences in languages used. Other barriers noted by this study’s participants ranged from 34.39% to 42.04% and included the high cost of infrastructure, the time it takes to learn teledentistry, fees, and resistance to technology. These should be taken into consideration as well, especially as some were reported in other studies. This indicates that teledentistry can be used, but some barriers should be tackled for better implementation.
One important aspect that should be discussed is the use of teledentistry during health crises such as the coronavirus pandemic. In fact, several studies highlighted the importance of using telehealth as an important alternative during such crises.,, In the light of current social distancing, movement restrictions, and affected healthcare systems,,,, teledentistry might be very useful to help dental patients in many aspects including consultation, triaging, and prescribing dental emergency medication. Indeed, current information does not give conclusive expectation to the future permitted spaces between dentist and patient, so teledentistry might be crucial to help minimizing the amount of unnecessary dentist–patient contact. Recently in China, 48 dental hospitals offered teledentistry for tertiary dental cases to cope with COVID-19 pandemic. Also, the American Teledentistry Association urged the use of teledentistry during the coronavirus pandemic; however, very few articles discuss this important topic because the coronavirus pandemic is a current problem. In addition, the study did not collect participant opinions about using teledentistry during a pandemic because data were collected in November 2019, before the onset of the first case of coronavirus in December 2019.
This study has a number of limitations. First, the self-administered questionnaire is prone to a self-reporting bias. Also, the external validity cannot be guaranteed because of the convenience sampling method that was used. Nevertheless, this study is likely one of only a few conducted in Saudi Arabia addressing this trending topic.
| Conclusions|| |
This study shows that, despite low awareness of the term “teledentistry” and a lack of knowledge about it, a considerable percentage of future dental professionals are using teledentistry in Saudi Arabia, just not systematically. Teledentistry can be a valuable venue for achieving Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030, and it is a suitable model for health crises such as the coronavirus pandemic. However, more education and greater efforts are needed to teach dental students how to use teledentistry properly. In addition, more efforts are required to overcome the barriers to teledentistry’s use, including patient privacy.
I would like to thank Tariq Althaqafi, Fawaz Alansari, Farah Shurayji, Noor Farsi, Waad Baroom, Samaher Bedaiwi, Shrooq Alzahrani, Ibtihal Alnuwaymi, Taghreed Almutairi, Sarah Alnefaie, Saja Asiri, Hani Al-Qataberi, and Fawaz Alharbi for helping with data collection.
Financial support and sponsorship
This study was self-funded.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
The author declare he is the only person who conduct the study idea, scientific study design, data analysis and interpretation and involved in manuscript writing.
Ethical policy and Institutional Review board statement
This study was approved by Umm Al-Qura University Institutional Review Board (129-19).
Patient declaration of consent
Data availability statement
Upon reasonable request, the data set analyzed during this study is available from the corresponding author (Dr. Khalid Aboalshamat, E-mail: [email protected]).
| References|| |
GBD 2015 Healthcare Access and Quality Collaborators. Healthcare access and quality index based on mortality from causes amenable to personal health care in 195 countries and territories, 1990–2015: A novel analysis from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015. Lancet 2017;390:231-66.
Jin LJ, Lamster IB, Greenspan JS, Pitts NB, Scully C, Warnakulasuriya S Global burden of oral diseases: Emerging concepts, management and interplay with systemic health. Oral Dis 2016;22:609-19.
Tanne JH, Hayasaki E, Zastrow M, Pulla P, Smith P, Rada AG Covid-19: How doctors and healthcare systems are tackling coronavirus worldwide. BMJ 2020;368:m1090.
Smith AC, Thomas E, Snoswell CL, Haydon H, Mehrotra A, Clemensen J, et al
. Telehealth for global emergencies: Implications for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). J Telemed Telecare 2020:1357633X20916567. [Epub ahead of print].
Chauhan V, Galwankar S, Arquilla B, Garg M, Somma SD, El-Menyar A, et al
. Novel coronavirus (COVID-19): Leveraging telemedicine to optimize care while minimizing exposures and viral transmission. J Emerg Trauma Shock 2020;13:20-4. [Full text]
Alkhamis AA Critical analysis and review of the literature on healthcare privatization and its association with access to medical care in Saudi Arabia. J Infect Public Health 2017;10:258-68.
AlBaker AA, Al-Ruthia YSH, AlShehri M, Alshuwairikh S The characteristics and distribution of dentist workforce in Saudi Arabia: A descriptive cross-sectional study. Saudi Pharm J 2017;25:1208-16.
Chen JW, Hobdell MH, Dunn K, Johnson KA, Zhang J Teledentistry and its use in dental education. J Am Dent Assoc 2003;134:342-6.
Robinson DF, Savage GT, Campbell KS Organizational learning, diffusion of innovation, and international collaboration in telemedicine. Health Care Manage Rev 2003;28:68-78.
Whitten PS, Mair FS, Haycox A, May CR, Williams TL, Hellmich S Systematic review of cost effectiveness studies of telemedicine interventions. BMJ 2002;324:1434-7.
Rocca MA, Kudryk VL, Pajak JC, Morris T The evolution of a teledentistry system within the Department of Defense. Proc AMIA Symp1999;1999:921-4.
Chang SW, Plotkin DR, Mulligan R, Polido JC, Mah JK, Meara JG Teledentistry in rural California: A USC initiative. J Calif Dent Assoc 2003;31:601-8.
Mariño R, Ghanim A Teledentistry: A systematic review of the literature. J Telemed Telecare 2013;19:179-83.
Brüllmann D, Schmidtmann I, Warzecha K, d’Hoedt B Recognition of root canal orifices at a distance: A preliminary study of teledentistry. J Telemed Telecare 2011;17:154-7.
Estai M, Kruger E, Tennant M Optimizing patient referrals to dental consultants: Implication of teledentistry in rural settings. Australas Med J 2016;9:249-52.
Yang Y, Zhou Y, Liu X, Tan J Health services provision of 48 public tertiary dental hospitals during the COVID-19 epidemic in China. Clin Oral Investig 2020;24:1861-4.
Hollander JE, Carr BG Virtually perfect? Telemedicine for covid-19. N Engl J Med 2020;382:1679-81.
Iacobucci G Covid-19: All non-urgent elective surgery is suspended for at least three months in England. BMJ 2020;368:m1106.
Wilder-Smith A, Freedman DO Isolation, quarantine, social distancing and community containment: Pivotal role for old-style public health measures in the novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) outbreak. J Travel Med 2020;27:taaa020.
Velavan TP, Meyer CG The COVID-19 epidemic. Trop Med Int Health 2020;25:278-80.
Daniel SJ, Kumar S Teledentistry: A key component in access to care. J Evid Based Dent Pract 2014;14:201-8.
Murererehe J, Uwambaye P, Isyagi M, Nyandwi T, Njunwa K Knowledge, attitude and practices of dental professionals in Rwanda towards the benefits and applications of teledentistry. Rwanda J Ser F: Med Health Sci 2017;4:39-47.
Pradhan D, Verma P, Sharma L, Khaitan T Knowledge, awareness, and attitude regarding teledentistry among postgraduate dental students of Kanpur city, India: A questionnaire study. J Educ Health Promot2019;8:104.
Ramesh N, Pankaj A, Archana JS, Kailash A, Mridula T, Piyush P, et al
. Teledentistry: Knowledge and attitudes among dentists in Udaipur, India. Oral Health Dent Manag 2013;12:138-44.
Tomar D, Menon I, Tyagi U, Singh A, Goyal J, Singh RP, Sharm A Assessment of awareness about teledentistry among dentists in a private dental college of Muradnagar, Ghaziabad. J Dent Spec 2018;6:8-12.
Groisman S, Olival R, Sampaio Filho H, Corvino M, Toledo E, Hidalgo R, et al
. Acceptance of teledentistry by Brazilian dentists. J Dent Health Oral Disord Ther 2015;3:250-3.
Latif N, Alam AN, Abdullah S Knowledge and attitude of dentists towards tele-dentistry in Pakistan. Pak Oral Dent J 2016;36:205-9.
Council of Economic and Development Affairs. KSA Vision 2030: Strategic objectives and vision realization programs. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: Minister of Energy, Industry & Mineral Resources Vision Realization Office; 2016. Available from: https://vro.meim.gov.sa/English/Documents%20library/Vision%20Realization%20Programs%20Overview_En.pdf. [Last accessed on 2020 Mar 20].
Boringi M, Waghray S, Lavanya R, Babu DB, Badam RK, Harsha N, et al
. Knowledge and awareness of teledentistry among dental professionals: A cross sectional study. J Clin Diagn Res 2015;9:ZC41-4.
Uluc CI, Ferman M A comparative analysis of user insights for e-health development challenges in Turkey, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Egypt and United Arab Emirates. J Manage Mark Logist 2016;3:176-89.
Alshahrani A, Stewart D, MacLure K A systematic review of the adoption and acceptance of eHealth in Saudi Arabia: Views of multiple stakeholders. Int J Med Inform 2019;128:7-17.
Aboalshamat K, Alkiyadi S, Alsaleh S, Reda R, Alkhaldi S, Badeeb A, et al
. Attitudes toward social media among practicing dentists and dental students in clinical years in Saudi Arabia. Open Dent J 2019;13:143-9.
Estai M, Bunt S, Kanagasingam Y, Kruger E, Tennant M Diagnostic accuracy of teledentistry in the detection of dental caries: A systematic review. J Evid Based Dent Pract 2016;16:161-72.
Ata SO, Ozkan S Information technology in oral health care: Attitudes of dental professionals on the use of teledentistry in Turkey. Proc Eur Mediterr Conf Inf Syst2009:1-8.
Watzlaf VJM, Zhou L, Dealmeida DR, Hartman LM A systematic review of research studies examining telehealth privacy and security practices used by healthcare providers. Int J Telerehabil 2017;9:39-59.
Alhashimi H “E-government strategy and its impact on economic and social development in Saudi Arabia.” In: Visvizi A, Lytras M, editors. Politics and Technology in the Post-Truth Era (Emerald Studies in Politics and Technology). Bingley, UK: Emerald Publishing; 2019. p. 237-43.
Ackerman M The importance of teledentistry during the coronavirus pandemic.Arlington, Virginia, United States: American TeleDentistry Association. 2020. Available from: https://www.americanteledentistry.org/the-importance-of-teledentistry-during-the-coronavirus-pandemic/. [Last accessed on 2020 Mar 20].
Riou J, Althaus CL Pattern of early human-to-human transmission of Wuhan 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV), December 2019 to January 2020. Euro Surveill 2020;25:2000058.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5]